Shelter Island, NY ZIP code
The ZIP code for Shelter Island, New York is 11964. It is in Suffolk County.
- Population in these ZIPs
- 2,906
- Avg. median income
- $134,600population-weighted
- Typical home value
- $1,796,500population-weighted
- Metro area
- New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ
Loading map…
Click anywhere on the map to see which ZIP code it's in.
Shelter Island, NY ZIP code list
| ZIP code | Population | Median income | Typical home value |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11964 | 2,906 | $134,620 | $1,796,500 |
Population and median household income: ACS 2020–2024 5-year estimates. Typical home value: Zillow Home Value Index (September 2026) where available, otherwise the ACS median owner-reported value. "PO Box" marks ZIP codes with no delivery area of their own. Methodology
Cities near Shelter Island
- Shelter Island Heights 2 mi
- Sag Harbor 3 mi
- Greenport 5 mi
- East Marion 6 mi
- East Hampton 7 mi
- Southold 7 mi
- Wainscott 8 mi
- Sagaponack 8 mi
- Peconic 8 mi
- Bridgehampton 8 mi
- Water Mill 9 mi
- New Suffolk 10 mi
Frequently asked questions
What is the ZIP code for Shelter Island, NY?
The ZIP code for Shelter Island, NY is 11964.
What county is Shelter Island, New York in?
Shelter Island ZIP codes are in Suffolk County.